How to Review a Paper

Posted September 27, 2016

External Article: Science

John Walsh, professor in the School of Public Policy, was quoted in "How to Review a Paper" by Science.

Excerpt:

I usually consider first the relevance to my own expertise. I will turn down requests if the paper is too far removed from my own research areas, since I may not be able to provide an informed review. Having said that, I tend to define my expertise fairly broadly for reviewing purposes. I also consider the journal. I am more willing to review for journals that I read or publish in. Before I became an editor, I used to be fairly eclectic in the journals I reviewed for, but now I tend to be more discerning, since my editing duties take up much of my reviewing time.

- John P. Walsh, professor of public policy at the Georgia Institute of Technology in Atlanta

For the full article, read here.